Skinny On

Tongue Rolling

Tongue Rolling


By Hannah Holmes

Everybody who stayed awake through the first nine minutes of high school biology knows the ability to roll your tongue into the shape of a tube is hereditary.

"We know it's a dominant trait," Wayne Carley, executive director of the National Association of Biology Teachers, told me.


"We teach it because it's an easy thing to test: You either can roll your tongue, or you can't."
.
A public-affairs person at the National Center for Genome Research confidently tells me the same thing. "If a child can, then at least one of her parents can."

But she's wrong. All the biology teachers are wrong, too.

The first clue turns up on a rap sheet kept by Genome Research. A short synopsis of tongue-rolling research is followed by the trait's inheritability status:

      "? autosomal dominant"


Grammatical issues aside, that's a funny place for a question mark.
.
"Well," says the woman who updates the database, a bit surprised to find the question mark there herself. "That means that the inheritance is not that secure."

And the more I root through the literature, the less secure I feel -- and not just because trait-trackers also investigate such hot items as "hand clasping," "arm folding" and "ear wax type," but because they turned up no evidence of inherited rollability.

Back in 1952 "Matlock" (scientists, like detectives, go by last name) concluded that identical twins don't always share the tongue-rolling trait. In 1975 "Martin" demonstrated that identical twins are no more likely to share tongue-rolling than are fraternal twins. In 1983 a Hungarian named Forrai found no genetic basis for tongue-curling -- or hand-clasping or arm-folding. And studying the Greeks of Thessaloniki in 1982, Cruz-Gonzalez established that while dry ear wax and attached ear lobes are recessive traits, which means you need the gene from both your parents, the genetic basis for tongue-rolling was less clear.

"But this could be due to difficulties in communication between the examined individual and the examiners," he cautions, which makes me wonder if the examined individuals were trying to talk with their tongues rolled up. (Try it. Now in Greek.)


In fairness the question of tongue-rolling isn't entirely resolved.
.
Solid as a Martin or Matlock study may seem today, tomorrow could bring contradictory findings equally convincing. This is how science staggers drunkenly toward the truth.

The happy news is that although tongue-rolling researchers have failed to exonerate your biology teacher, they have produced some very high-grade, if useless, trivia: In Spain 67 percent of females can roll their tongues, compared to just 64 percent of men. But Spanish men are twice as likely to wiggle their ears (20 percent) as are women. And an Iranian researcher discovered a dearth of tongue-rollers in Northern England, which, he concludes mysteriously, "may be due to mixture with Scandinavians." And hand-clasping -- concerning which thumb ends up on top -- seems related to handedness.

When I tell Wayne Carley what I've discovered, he gets a little quiet. Maybe he's contemplating rewriting all the textbooks to replace "tongue rolling" with "ear wax."


Vocabulary
Geographic tongue, n. In this disorder patches of the papillae that make your tongue rough disappear temporarily. The bald spots may migrate in a fascinating pageant of continental drift.


Check out more of "The Skinny On..." stories:

Traffic Jam "Ghosts"

Why Asparagus Makes Your Pee Stink

Why We Can't Tell What Time It Is

Why We Fear Nuclear Power, Not Peanut Butter


Hannah Holmes lives in Portland, Maine and can roll her tongue. Her numerous contributions to Discovery Online include "Hitchhikers' Guide to the Hubble". She also writes for Escape, Outside, Sierra, Backpacker, Eco Traveler and Women's Sports and Fitness. Write her at skinny@online.discovery.com.


S K I N N Y  O N
Main
WebLinks




Illustration: Brian Frick |
Copyright © 1997 Discovery Communications, Inc.