Artwork of the solar system, showing the paths of the eight major planets as they orbit the Sun. The four inner planets are, from inner to outer, Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars. The four outer planets are, inner to outer, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune. Pluto is also shown, beyond Neptune.

623681709

Artwork of the solar system, showing the paths of the eight major planets as they orbit the Sun. The four inner planets are, from inner to outer, Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars. The four outer planets are, inner to outer, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune. Pluto is also shown, beyond Neptune.

Photo by: MARK GARLICK/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

MARK GARLICK/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

Life on Venus… Maybe Not So Lively

All planets with evidence of life please take a step forward. Not so fast, Venus.

November 19, 2020

A few weeks ago the astronomy world was rocked by the announcement of the discovery of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus. For the uninitiated, phosphine is one atom of phosphorus bound to three atoms of oxygen, and while stinky, it's relatively unexciting. However (and this is why anybody cares, at all), under normal conditions (as in, not the inside of a giant planet with all the crazy-high temperatures and pressures), the only thing that makes phosphine in any considerable quantity is anaerobic bacteria.

You know, life.

So phosphorus in the clouds of Venus was promoted as a potential sign of life, which is quite a surprise given that Earth’s sister is a roasting hellscape of rocks and pain. That would be a big deal, if the results held up.

It doesn’t seem that the results are holding up.

It now looks like there may not be any phosphine at all in the atmosphere of Venus, and that the original results were more a case of wishful thinking than careful science, according to a recent study.

To explain what’s going on, we have to talk about spectra. I know, I know, but welcome to astronomy.

If you shoot a beam of light into a prism and enjoy the resulting rainbow, you’re looking at a (rudimentary) spectrum–you’re looking at what the beam of light is made of. So many blues, so many greens, so many reds, and so on.

We can use spectra like this to tell what things are made of in space, because elements and molecules leave their own particular fingerprints in the spectrum. For example, if you’ve ever wondered why the grass is green, it’s because chlorophyll (the little chemical engine that converts sunlight into food) has a strong green fingerprint in the spectrum of sunlight reflected off a plant.

It’s through looking at the spectrum of sunlight bouncing off Venus that the original astronomers said that the planet has phosphine, because they thought they saw the distinct fingerprint of that molecule in the spectrum.

Slam dunk, right?

Well, one of the issues is that another molecule, sulfur dioxide, has a very, very similar fingerprint. It’s so similar to the fingerprint of phosphine that the original data couldn’t convincingly distinguish the two, as argued by the new study. So what the original group claimed was exotic, unexpected, signs-of-life phosphine could really be boring, dull, lifeless sulfur dioxide.

More About Venus

When Was There Life on Venus?

What we have is a cosmic whodunit. Venus, the second planet from the sun and considered by the more romantic types as "Earth's twin" and the avatar of love, is dead.

Venus the Temperate, Earth’s "Twisted Sister"

A new study gives insight into Venus' climatic history.

Is There Life on Venus? Something Smells Fishy…

Does the presence of a stinky gas mean there was once life on Venus?

The second issue has to do with how fantastically bright Venus is. It’s the brightest object in the sky after the sun and moon, and our sensitive astronomical instruments are usually more tuned to distant, faint sources. Ironically, it’s harder to observe Venus with state of the art observatories than it is, say, a distant galaxy on the other side of the universe.

All that brightness means a flood of light that causes a heck of a lot of noise in the spectrum. You have to be extremely careful when filtering out that noise, however, because you don’t know ahead of time what’s useful data telling you about molecular fingerprints, and what’s useless junk.

The new study points out that the original analysis of the spectrum of Venus included a lot of…well, let’s just call it wishful thinking, where their chosen technique to remove the noise made a phosphine signal appear where there really isn’t one.

In the end we’ll need more data to settle the score, but in the meantime, we can probably put to rest any dreams of shaking hands with our planetary neighbors (not that you’d want to ever visit Venus in the first place, but that’s a different story).

Paul M. Sutter

Paul M. Sutter is an astrophysicist at Stony Brook University and the Flatiron Institute, host of Ask a Spaceman and Space Radio, and author of How to Die in Space.

Next Up

Why Astronomers Care About Super-Old Galaxies?

A long time ago, our universe was dark.It was just 380,000 years after the big bang. Up until that age, our entire observable cosmos was less than a millionth of its present size. All the material in the universe was compressed into that tiny volume, forcing it to heat up and become a plasma. But as the universe expanded and cooled, eventually the plasma changed into a neutral gas as the first atoms formed.

What We’ve Already Learned From James Webb? (Hint: it’s a lot)

That was worth the wait. Just a quick handful of months since its historic launch on Christmas Day, the James Webb Space Telescope has flown to its observing position, unfolded its delicate instruments and ultra-sized mirror, and run through a suite of checks and alignments and calibrations. The team at NASA behind the telescopes released their first batch of images from the science runs, and besides being gorgeous, they're powerful.

A Guide to this August’s Best Astronomy Attractions

Learn more about the exciting things happening in the night sky this month! From the rings of Saturn to the most popular meteor shower of the year, August 2022 has us stargazing all month.

How Astronomers Use a Trick of Gravity to See the Most Distant Objects in the Universe

Let’s say you’re an astronomer (work with me here) and you want to take a picture of something incredibly, deeply far away. You know, the typical business of astronomy.

How Exoplanets Became the Next Big Thing in Astronomy

To date, we know of over 5,000 planets outside the solar system. And astronomers suspect that there may be *checks notes* around a trillion more in our galaxy alone. The search for exoplanets is one of the hottest topics in astronomy, with expensive telescopes and giant collaborations all searching for the holy grail of the 21st century: an Earth 2.0, a habitable world like our own.

South Korea Joins Space Race by Sending its First Spacecraft to the Moon

South Korea is launching its first lunar probe to the moon on August 4th. The Korea Pathfinder Lunar Orbiter (KPLO) or Danuri, developed by the Korea Aerospace Research Institute (KARI) is being launched to study moon carters, magnetic fields, and surface weathering.

You Love Supernova, So How About Micronova?

In space, even the smallest explosions are insanely powerful. Take for instance the newly discovered “micronova,” which sounds cute and cuddly and not at all deadly…except for the fact that it’s the explosive equivalent of a nuclear bomb a million times bigger than Mount Everest.

6 Months in Space Permanently Ages Bones by 10 Years

Astronauts on long-term space missions can experience bone loss equivalent to two decades of aging. New research suggests more weight-bearing exercises in space could help offset that decline.

The Perseid Meteor Shower Reaches its Peak

Stargazers rejoice! The annual Perseid meteor shower is upon us. Here's what you need to know...(updated August 11, 2022)

Jupiter Makes Its Closest Approach to Earth in Nearly 60 Years

The last time Jupiter appeared this large and bright in the sky was in October 1963.

Related To: