The VLA (Very Large Array Observatorium) in one of New Mexico's observatory where scientists are seeking extraterrestrial life in the universe with the help of radio waves, Magdalena Ridge Observatory, Socorro county, central New Mexico. (Photo by plus49/Construction Photography/Avalon/Getty Images)

976208308

The VLA (Very Large Array Observatorium) in one of New Mexico's observatory where scientists are seeking extraterrestrial life in the universe with the help of radio waves, Magdalena Ridge Observatory, Socorro county, central New Mexico. (Photo by plus49/Construction Photography/Avalon/Getty Images)

Photo by: Construction Photography/Avalon

Construction Photography/Avalon

Top 5 Reasons Why the “UFO Report” Isn’t Interesting to me, a Scientist

Excited by the prospects of the “UFO Report”? As a scientist, I have my doubts.

But you can watch UFOS DECLASSIFED: LIVE on Discovery and Science June 30 at 8P where experts discuss what can and can't be explained.

June 26, 2021
@discovery

Do you believe in #aliens? Why or why not?👽 Astrophysicist @paulmattsutter explains the #UFO report #learnontiktok #tiktokpartner #thetruthisoutthere

♬ original sound - Discovery

#5: We’re All Alone, Man

We’ve spent 70 years searching the sky for signs of alien radio communication. We haven’t heard squat. Either nobody’s out there, or all the aliens are ghosting us. We’ve looked for life in all the planets of the solar system, and the thousands of planets known to orbit other stars. Also squat.

As far as we can tell, we are absolutely alone in the universe. I mean, sure, there may be life out there, but because we haven’t seen any yet, it means it must be pretty rare. So either we really do have the universe all to ourselves, or we might as well have the universe all to ourselves because it’s pretty empty out there.

#4: Space is Huge

1208252785

Photo by: shunli zhao

shunli zhao

Speaking of empty, do you know how big space is? Our nearest neighbor star is Proxima Centauri. It’s a little less than four light-years away. That doesn’t sound like much, but our fastest space probes would take tens of thousands of years to reach it-if they were even pointed in the right direction. Which they’re not.

Yes, it’s possible to conceive of faster spacecraft, but it all takes ridiculous amounts of energy. And don’t even get me started on faster-than-light travel. That’s a different rant.

#3: Earth is Boring

Clouds float above the Inner Mongolia Prairie,Hulun Buir City,Inner Mongolia,China

503903052

Clouds float above the Inner Mongolia Prairie,Hulun Buir City,Inner Mongolia,China

Photo by: xia yuan

xia yuan

If aliens did exist and could cross the vast interstellar gulfs in a reasonable amount of time, why would they come here? We’re just a giant ball of silicon and oxygen and water. If you’re interested in mining, there are tons of asteroids just hanging around, not doing anything that are way easier to access.

I suppose aliens might be interested in our culture. But keep in mind, we’ve been broadcasting TV into space for over half a decade, so ask yourself if you would want to visit after seeing that.

#2: Sometimes the Military Hides Stuff

WASHINGTON, DC - MARCH 29:  A group of protestors march in front of the General  Accounting Office (GAO) 29 March to raise awarness about an examination being conducted by the GAO for documents about a weather balloon crash at Roswell, N.M. in 1947. The protestors believe the balloon was a crashed UFO.  AFP PHOTO  (Photo credit should read JOSHUA ROBERTS/AFP via Getty Images)

51970887

1995: A group of protestors march in front of the General Accounting Office (GAO) to raise awarness about an examination being conducted by the GAO for documents about a weather balloon crash at Roswell, N.M. in 1947. The protestors believe the balloon was a crashed UFO.

Photo by: JOSHUA ROBERTS

JOSHUA ROBERTS

1995: A group of protestors march in front of the General Accounting Office (GAO) to raise awarness about an examination being conducted by the GAO for documents about a weather balloon crash at Roswell, N.M. in 1947. The protestors believe the balloon was a crashed UFO.

I’m just putting this out there, that militaries around the world like to keep a bunch of stuff secret, even when they say they aren’t keeping secrets. So the UFO sightings might be drone technology from our own military or somebody else’s (or just a bunch of teenagers having fun).

#1: We Don’t Know

687213653

Photo by: Buena Vista Images

Buena Vista Images

They are called unidentified flying objects for a reason. We don’t know what they are. If you see something weird happening in the sky that you can’t name, congratulations — you’ve just spotted a UFO. You can say that they’re aliens, but that’s making a big jump: you’re claiming to identify them. Just because you don’t know what they are doesn’t give you permission to…know what they are. That’s not how evidence works.

Are there aliens out there in the universe? Probably. Have they visited the Earth? Probably not. Could the UFOs be aliens? Sure, they could be. But the bar for accepting evidence in science is pretty dang high, and a bunch of unexplained blurry lights isn’t going to cut it.

Paul M. Sutter

Paul M. Sutter is an astrophysicist at Stony Brook University and the Flatiron Institute, host of Ask a Spaceman and Space Radio, and author of How to Die in Space.

Next Up

Jupiter Makes Its Closest Approach to Earth in Nearly 60 Years

The last time Jupiter appeared this large and bright in the sky was in October 1963.

Got You! Astronomers Find an Especially Sneaky Black Hole

Black holes are tricky creatures. Since ancient times the practice of astronomy has been to point our eyes and instruments at all the glowing things in the skies above us. But black holes are defined by the fact that nothing, not even light, can escape their gravitational clutches. So how you do see something that is completely, totally black?

Six Planets are Retrograde, What Does that Mean for You?

Spoiler alert: It's an optical illusion.

Asteroid Ryugu Has Dust Grains Older Than the Sun. How?

In 2018 the Japanese space agency sent the Hayabusa2 mission to the asteroid Ryugu, As a part of that mission, the spacecraft blasted material off the surface of the asteroid, put it in a bottle, and sent it back to Earth. Two years later that sample landed in the western deserts of Australia.

Why We Know Nothing about Dark Matter and Dark Energy

Welcome to the era of precision cosmology…where we’ve managed to very precisely measure everything we don't know about the universe.

What We Learn from the Lunar Surface

Sure, the Moon is cool to look at, and fun to think about it. And it literally affects us here on the Earth: without the Moon, we’d be missing half our tides, and likely our planet’s rotation wouldn’t be as stable as it is.

What Comes After the Moon and Mars?

Space hotels may be in our future.

Watch NASA's Asteroid-Crashing DART Mission Make Impact

NASA sent a spacecraft on a mission to crash into an asteroid, so how did it go?Updated 9/26/22

Want to Name a Planet? Now’s Your Chance

Read on to learn about this rare opportunity to name a distant world observed by the James Webb Telescope.

What Screaming Black Holes are Telling Us

In 2002, NASA’s orbiting X-ray observatory, the Chandra telescope, mapped out the movements of hot gas in a cluster of galaxies sitting 250 million light-years away.

Related To: