Photo by: NASA/JPL

NASA/JPL

Is There Life on Venus? Something Smells Fishy…

Does the presence of a stinky gas mean there was once life on Venus?

September 14, 2020

Phosphine is one of the grossest chemicals out there. Not because of what it’s made of–one atoms of phosphorus and three atoms of hydrogen–but because it’s really, really stinky. It’s commonly associated with decaying organic matter, if you need a mental picture. It occurs naturally through a variety of processes, most notably as a byproduct of non-oxygen-using life. But since oxygen-using life is quite common on our planet, thankfully this stinky chemical is relatively rare.

Who Stank?

Phosphine or phosphane is the compound with the chemical formula PH3. It is a colorless, flammable, toxic gas and pnictogen hydride. 3d illustration

660674942

Phosphine or phosphane is the compound with the chemical formula PH3. It is a colorless, flammable, toxic gas and pnictogen hydride.

Photo by: ollaweila

ollaweila

Phosphine or phosphane is the compound with the chemical formula PH3. It is a colorless, flammable, toxic gas and pnictogen hydride.

Recently some astronomers have been raising a big stink (pun very much intended) about Earth’s sister planet, Venus. For those of you new to Venus: don’t go. It’s a nightmarish hellhole of a planet, choking on so much poisonous carbon dioxide that its surface pressure is over 90 times that of sea level. The temperatures at the surface are hot enough to melt lead. It rains sulfuric acid.

It’s nasty. And it just might–might – be a home for life.


A certain subgroup of astronomers known as astrobiologists (and yes, that’s a thing) are hunting for signs of life outside the Earth. One of the most promising ways is to look for (and this is a pretty awesome jargon word) biosignatures. These are signs of life in the form of chemicals that don’t normally come from chemical (i.e., boring unless you’re a chemist) processes.

An example of this is oxygen. The vast majority of the oxygen in our atmosphere comes as a byproduct of photosynthesis (in other words: life). If we were to find a lot of oxygen in another planet’s atmosphere, it just might be teeming with little critters.

Another potential biosignature is stinky molecule phosphine. Sure, it’s possible to create phosphine naturally, but it takes a lot of energy, and is very unstable–the UV radiation from the sun does a really good job at breaking it apart.

I’ll cut to the chase: a group of astronomers recently announced the presence of a load of phosphine in the atmosphere of Venus. A potential sign of life in basically the last place you would expect to find it.

Now we also see a lot of phosphine in the atmospheres of Jupiter and Saturn, and we really don’t think it comes from life on those giant planets–more likely it originates in some super-intense chemical process deep in their interiors.

But Venus?

Venus, computer artwork.

460713161

Venus, computer artwork.

Photo by: SCIEPRO

SCIEPRO

The astronomers argue that they’ve thought of every possible way to make lots of phosphine in Venus without involving life, and keep coming up short.

Where could life exist in that hellscape? Well, a few dozen miles up in the atmosphere is pretty clement: room temperatures and standard air pressures. The air is still full of noxious carbon dioxide and sulfuric acid, but hey life has found footholds in stranger places.

But still, as with all stories of this nature, I urge caution and skepticism. Venus is a strange, strange environment that we barely even pretend to understand. Lots of crazy chemistry could be going on. There have been hints of life on Mars for decades that have been undermined by further study, and the same is likely true for Venus. By the time the news excitement dies down, there is likely to be a dozen hypothetical processes proposed that could explain the strange presence of phosphine on Venus.

Which is exciting if you’re into cool, weird chemistry, but not so exciting if you’re into life.

Paul M. Sutter

Paul M. Sutter is an astrophysicist at Stony Brook University and the Flatiron Institute, host of Ask a Spaceman and Space Radio, and author of How to Die in Space.

Next Up

NASA's New Rocket is Taller than the Statue of Liberty

The massive space launch system was unveiled last week. Following successful completion of upcoming simulation tests, NASA will set a date for the first of the Artemis II lunar missions.

What Screaming Black Holes are Telling Us

In 2002, NASA’s orbiting X-ray observatory, the Chandra telescope, mapped out the movements of hot gas in a cluster of galaxies sitting 250 million light-years away.

When We’ll Know if NASA’s Asteroid Impact Test was a Success

Recently NASA’s DART mission succeeded in its primary goal, which was to slam a spacecraft face-first into an asteroid. For science. The intention of the mission was to test if we could actually redirect an asteroid and send it into a different orbit. But how and when will we know if it worked?

The Nobel Prize Fell Into a Black Hole (and That’s a Good Thing)

The 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics is being awarded to scientists to have dedicated their careers to the study of black holes.

Watch NASA's Asteroid-Crashing DART Mission Make Impact

NASA sent a spacecraft on a mission to crash into an asteroid, so how did it go?Updated 9/26/22

Want to Name a Planet? Now’s Your Chance

Read on to learn about this rare opportunity to name a distant world observed by the James Webb Telescope.

Astronomers May Have Found a Rare “Free-Floating” Black Hole

How do you see a perfectly black object in the middle of a pitch-dark night? It sounds like the start of an annoying riddle, but it’s really the question faced by astronomers when they want to search for black holes.

Watch Out! Amateur Astronomer Watches as Jupiter Gets Whacked

Jupiter is the OG best friend in the solar system. It finds all the tiny little comets and asteroids heading for the vulnerable inner planets and takes one for the team, chewing up the dangerous rocks in its thick atmosphere. It happened again just recently, and this time an amateur astronomer caught it in the act.

Watch the Super Flower Blood Moon Total Lunar Eclipse

Those located in the Americas, Europe, or Africa can see this rare total lunar eclipse during the night of May 15, 2022.

Six Planets are Retrograde, What Does that Mean for You?

Spoiler alert: It's an optical illusion.

Related To: