ESA/Hubble & NASA

What is “Dark Flow”?

It sounds super-scary: something from outside the universe, a force so unimaginable, is pulling every single galaxy towards it. What monstrosity of cosmic physics could it be?

November 05, 2021

It’s the dark flow.

At least the good news is that we don’t know if it exists, and even if it did it wouldn’t be that big of a deal.

Everything in our universe is constantly moving. Planets orbit stars. Stars dance within galaxies. And generally, on average, galaxies are getting further apart from each other. This is the expansion of the universe, first discovered by astronomer Edwin Hubble in the 1920s. According to our best observations, and our understanding of the evolution of the universe, this expansion is uniform. It’s the same in all directions. Once you get to big enough scales, galaxies just move out without any other preferred direction.

Bettmann

Dr. Edwin P. Hubble, who first discovered "dark flow."

But at smaller scales, there can be some very interesting dynamics. For example, our own galaxy, the Milky Way, is on a collision course with our nearest neighbor, the Andromeda Galaxy. In about five billion years our galaxies will collide in a titanic collision, and if our descendants are around to see the show it will be quite spectacular.

On top of that motion, both the Milky Way and Andromeda are heading towards the Virgo Cluster, a dense cosmic city home to about a thousand galaxies.

Natapong Supalertsophon

The Milky Way is moving.

And there’s more. The Milky Way, Andromeda, the Virgo Cluster itself, and all the other galaxies in our nearby patch of space are together moving in the direction of an even bigger cluster, the Norma Cluster, located in a region of space known as the Great Attractor.

Here’s where things start to get tricky. The further out we go in our observations, the harder it gets to pinpoint the precise movements of galaxies. Compounding that, astronomers are really good at measuring the movement of galaxies toward or away from us (based on the shifting of light from the galaxies), but calculating movements in other directions is much harder. So we have to rely on computer modeling to make an educated guess.

While most observations of the larger universe have held up the “expanding uniformly in all directions” point of view, some inconsistencies have emerged. Some observations have seen a tiny, subtle, blink-and-you-miss-it movement. It appears that many galaxies might be moving in a preferred direction, instead of just uniformly outwards.

ESA/Hubble & NASA

Andromeda is moving toward the Norma Cluster.

This is the “dark flow” because it’s an unexplained motion observed in the behavior of galaxies. Like a flock of birds veering to one side, you have to ask: what’s making them go in that direction?

It could be caused by some catastrophe in the early universe, setting up a motion that took billions of years to unfold. It could be something frighteningly massive lying just outside the edge of the visible universe, tugging at all of its with its almost-imperceptible gravity. It could also be just a mistake or bias in the data, an artifact of our inadequate observations.

Whatever it is, the dark flow is nothing to worry about. If it does exist, it’s just a tiny effect that isn’t going to tear apart the universe or jump out from under the bed.

Sleep tight.

Journey Through the Cosmos in an All-New Season of How the Universe Works

The new season premieres March 24 on Science Channel and streams on discovery+.

Paul M. Sutter is an astrophysicist at Stony Brook University and the Flatiron Institute, host of Ask a Spaceman and Space Radio, and author of How to Die in Space.

Next Up

Top 5 Reasons Why the “UFO Report” Isn’t Interesting to me, a Scientist

Excited by the prospects of the “UFO Report”? As a scientist, I have my doubts. But you can watch UFOS DECLASSIFED: LIVE on Discovery and Science June 30 at 8P where experts discuss what can and can't be explained.

Do You Want to Go to Space?

Have you always dreamed of going to space? Former NASA astronaut Mike Massimino answers our questions about life at the International Space Station.

We Have Liftoff: Congratulations to NASA and SpaceX

Here's to NASA, SpaceX, Astronauts Bob Behnken and Doug Hurley, and all of the engineers, scientists, and staff involved with the Saturday, May 30th historical launch.

Quiz: Test Your Space Exploration Knowledge

Ahead of the historic May 27th NASA and SpaceX crewed space launch, test your space exploration knowledge!

NFL SUPER STADIUMS Follows the Epic Journey of Building SoFi Stadium

In partnership with the NFL, Discovery and Science Channel go behind the scenes and follow the remarkable journey of constructing SoFi Stadium in an all-new, two-hour special, NFL SUPER STADIUMS premiering Wednesday, September 9 at 8P on Science Channel and Saturday, September 12 at 11A on Discovery.

What is the Multiverse?

What if there was another you, somewhere out there, doing all the things you wished you could’ve done? What if there was a multiverse, where all the possibilities and choices of our lives became real? It seems like just another fantasy of science fiction, but it’s closer to reality than you might think.

What We’ve Already Learned From James Webb? (Hint: it’s a lot)

That was worth the wait. Just a quick handful of months since its historic launch on Christmas Day, the James Webb Space Telescope has flown to its observing position, unfolded its delicate instruments and ultra-sized mirror, and run through a suite of checks and alignments and calibrations. The team at NASA behind the telescopes released their first batch of images from the science runs, and besides being gorgeous, they're powerful.

What are the Chances of Life Appearing On…Earth?

Just how lucky are we on Earth? What were the chances that life would arise, let alone lead to intelligence?

May Sky Watch: What to Look Out For This Month

Whether you can see it from home or stream it online, here are some of May's wonderous celestial events.

Stuck at Home? What to See in the Night Sky this Month

In times of darkness and incertainty, opt for exploration of wonder in the skies.

Related To: