Communication Satellite Orbiting Earth. Realistic 3D Scene.

Communication Satellite Orbiting Earth

Communication Satellite Orbiting Earth. Realistic 3D Scene.

Photo by: NASA

NASA

The Cost of Global Satellite Internet: Worse Astronomy

A few billionare-backed companies have ambitious goals: launching tens of thousands of communication satellites to provide global high-speed internet access. Elon Musk’s StarLink, Jeff Bezos’ Project Kuiper, One Web, GuoWang, and more are all competing for this lucrative market. In less than a decade, we can expect over 50,000 new satellites to encircle the Earth. That’s about ten times more than are currently active.

September 30, 2021

Global high-speed internet access is largely a good thing, especially for people in remote or developing areas with otherwise poor infrastructure.

But (and you knew there was going to be a “but) there is a downside. All those satellites carry reflective solar panels. Which makes them bright and a nuisance for astronomy.

Let’s say you’re an astronomer. You’ve just invested an enormous amount of money developing a gigantic, world-class telescope. You begin science operations and take photograph after photograph of the night sky. Prior to the arrival of these “mega-constellations”, you might occasionally see one or two satellite streaks in your images every once in a while. No biggie – you just toss those out. You’ve got plenty of good data to spare.

NASA

Photo by: NASA

NASA

But after all these satellites launch and multiple companies are offering their global internet services? It makes almost every night a bad night.

While the satellites don’t affect all of astronomy, some observing programs are impacted more than others. High-altitude orbiting telescopes, for example, are much closer to the mega-constellations and hence more likely to get contaminated images. Telescopes that try to take as wide an image as possible will have their results junked up. The problem is especially worse in the early evening and just before dawn, when the angle between the satellites and the sun makes for maximum glare.

Photo by: NASA

NASA

Unfortunately, there’s no simple, single way to have both global satellite internet and uncontaminated astronomy. Instead, we have to employ a variety of mitigation techniques:

  • Beg and plead with the companies to alter the color and shape of their satellites, to lessen their brightness. Unfortunately the companies are under no legal obligation to do anything about it.
  • Use computers to model where the satellites will be to make sure an observation program doesn’t cross paths. This will reduce the amount of contaminated data…because we’ll be taking less data. So less astronomy will get done every night.
  • Remove the satellite trails from the images after the observation. This can be done, kind of, in a vague but not very satisfying way.

So what do we do about this? If we want to preserve the practice of astronomy – which is by and large funded by public government programs – then we need to have major discussions now, before even more satellites go up. If we even wait a few years, then it will essentially be too late. Maybe we as a society are willing to have slightly sub-optimal astronomy observing programs in exchange for the benefits of global internet access. Maybe not. But until we start talking about it, we can’t ever make up our minds.

Dive Deeper into the Cosmos

Journey Through the Cosmos in an All-New Season of How the Universe Works

Watch episodes on Science Channel and stream on discovery+.

Paul M. Sutter

Paul M. Sutter is an astrophysicist at Stony Brook University and the Flatiron Institute, host of Ask a Spaceman and Space Radio, and author of How to Die in Space.

Next Up

Romeo and Juliet: The Story of Galaxy Collisions

Our Milky Way galaxy is on a collision course. With destiny. With destruction. With fate. With our nearest neighbor, Andromeda. You can stream HOW THE UNIVERSE WORKS on discovery+.

Anatomy Lesson: The Milky Way

The Milky Way is a giant, sprawling, beautiful spiral galaxy. It's also your home. Let's take a little tour.

From the Moon to the Oval Office

As homage to the past Apollo Missions and a nod to the upcoming Artemis Program, NASA recently loaned the White House a lunar sample that has been placed in the President’s Oval Office. You can learn more about the Apollo missions and beyond on discovery+.

The New Warp Drive Idea Isn’t Very Warpy

Headline after headline is sharing the exciting news: a pair of theoretical physicists have realized that our sci-fi dreams may be real: it may be possible to build an actual, operational warp drive. One problem: it doesn’t go all that fast.

Going for Gold: The Biggest Explosion in the Universe

Meet the humble Ophiuchus galaxy cluster. It’s just another dense clump of galaxies, one of approximately a bajillion, dotting the universe. It sits about 240 million lightyears away from Earth.And its heart is missing.

The Top 5 Weirdest Moons of the Solar System

From the exotic to the just plain odd, our solar system is home to some of the most extreme worlds in the galaxy. But I’m not talking about the planets, I’m talking about their moons. Let’s take a look at the most strange...

What Do Pulsar Waves Tell Us About the Universe?

Using a network of dead stars, astronomers get closer to seeing the background ripples of the universe.

The Milky Way Broke its Arm (But is Totally Okay)

The Milky Way is a giant, magnificent, truly transcendently beautiful spiral arm galaxy. It’s too bad we can’t get a decent picture of it. The problem is that we live inside it, and so astronomers have to work extra-hard to construct an accurate map.

It’s Time to Return to the Land of the Ice Giants

30 years--It’s been over 30 years since the Voyager 2’s historic flyby of Uranus and Neptune, the outermost and most mysterious planets in the solar system. It’s time to go back.

Celebrate the I Heart Pluto Festival, An Ode to the Beloved Planet

Yes, we said "planet." Clyde Tombaugh discovered Pluto at Lowell Observatory in Flagstaff, Arizona during the month of February in 1930.Last year on the 90th Anniversary of the discovery, the observatory held its first I Heart Pluto Festival. This year you can be a part of the action.

Related To: