Why Pluto Isn’t a Planet, but (Maybe) Should Be

What, exactly, is a “planet”? For ancient astronomers it was pretty easy. When they stared up at the night sky, they saw a) the sun, b) the moon, c) a lot of fixed stars, d) a few wandering points of light. Those vagabonds were the planets. Indeed, our word planet comes from the Greek word for “wanderer”.

October 18, 2021

All this was fine and dandy until the mid-1800’s when astronomers discovered Ceres, a large object between the orbits of Mars and Jupiter. At first, it was classified as a planet – and why not, it seemed like any other wandered. But then we discovered more and more objects in the same general patch of space, and ended up reclassifying the whole gang as “asteroids”.

Then in 1930 American astronomer, Clyde Tombaugh discovered Pluto, way far out beyond the orbit of Neptune. From the beginning, Pluto was weird. It was really small. It had a really elongated, elliptical orbit. Sometimes it was closer to the sun than Neptune, and sometimes it wasn’t. It had a moon, Charon, that was almost as big as it. Its orbit was on a really janky angle, not lining up with the other planets.

Every family has that one weird relative, and so Pluto was simply thought of as the oddest of the planets.

And yet, nobody had bothered to define what a “planet” really was.

Photo by: NASA


Things started to get heated in the late 1990s when astronomers started to find other large objects in the same general patch of space as Pluto. Sound familiar? Should these new objects be added to the planetary family, or was a reclassification in order?

In 2006 the International Astronomical Union (IAU), the group of astronomers who decided that they’re in charge of deciding such things, put the question of Pluto to a vote (during a conference in Hawaii, no less). To decide if Pluto was a planet or not, they had to finally get around to defining the word “planet”. Here’s what they came up with.

To be a planet, you have to satisfy three criteria:

1) You must orbit the sun

2) You must be large enough so that your own gravity makes you round

3) You must clear your orbit of any other junk – in other words, you must “dominate” the region of your orbit

Pluto definitely fits 1) and 2), but definition 3) was added to specifically remove Pluto, and all its friends, from the planet list. Since there are so many objects in the vicinity of Pluto’s orbit, it got disqualified.

Photo by: NASA, ESA, and M. Buie/Southwest Research Institute

NASA, ESA, and M. Buie/Southwest Research Institute

Pluto was then reclassified as a “dwarf planet”, along with Ceres in the asteroid belt.

So is Pluto a planet? Technically, no. According to the IAU, there are only 8 planets in the solar system.

Photo by: NASA


But if you see a picture of Pluto, it looks like a planet. It’s round, large, and has interesting surface features. It looks nothing at all like Ceres, its sibling dwarf planet. It likely had a very different formation history than Ceres. Indeed, Pluto has a more dynamic surface than Mars does.

In truth, many astronomers, when writing about Pluto and discussing Pluto, toss around the word “planet” anyway, because it feels like a planet. In over 200 years of planetary science, almost nobody had used “clearing the orbit” to describe planets.

A small but dedicated group of astronomers is attempting to redefine the word “planet”, striking definition 3) off the list. Yes, it might mean that our solar system would have dozens – if not hundreds or thousands – of planets. But there are hundreds of billions of “stars” in the Milky Way, and that doesn’t seem to bother anybody.

Dive Deeper into the Cosmos

Journey Through the Cosmos in an All-New Season of How the Universe Works

The new season premieres March 24 on Science Channel and streams on discovery+.

Paul M. Sutter

Paul M. Sutter is an astrophysicist at Stony Brook University and the Flatiron Institute, host of Ask a Spaceman and Space Radio, and author of How to Die in Space.

Next Up

What Is a “Super Earth” and Why Do We Care?

Super Earths are super cool, and you should really know about them. In short, they are planets slightly bigger than the Earth (hence the name). And the cool part? They might be a home for life, and they’re way easier to study than regular Earths.

NASA is Going Back to Venus. Here’s Why You Should Care.

Recently NASA announced two brand-spanking new missions to our sister planet, Venus. This is the first time in over 40 years that Americans have led a mission to that enigmatic planet. What do they hope to find? Clues to our past…and answers to our future.

It’s Time to Return to the Land of the Ice Giants

30 years--It’s been over 30 years since the Voyager 2’s historic flyby of Uranus and Neptune, the outermost and most mysterious planets in the solar system. It’s time to go back.

How Common are Water Worlds in the Galaxy?

If Kevin Costner wanted to make a sequel, he’s got plenty of opportunities. Water is by far the most common molecule in the universe. It’s made of two parts hydrogen and one part oxygen. Hydrogen is element number 1 (both on the period table and in abundance), and has been hanging around since the first 15 minutes of the Big Bang. Oxygen is forged in the hearts of sun-like stars, and spreads around when those stars die and turn themselves inside out. And since sun-like stars are also very popular, oxygen gets quite a boost.

A Jupiter-Sized Exoplanet Orbiting Two Stars

One of my favorite things about exoplanet systems is just how weird they can get. It seems that every few months we are treated to another surprise. This time around, NASA's TESS observatory delivered a planet almost three times more massive than Jupiter orbiting around not one, but two stars. As an added bonus: that planet orbits its twin suns closer than the Earth does around the sun. Who wants to take a trip?

All Hail Ganymede, King of the Moons

NASA’s Juno probe, the supremely awesome Jupiter orbiter, recently captured some stunning images of Ganymede, the largest moon of Jupiter, during the orbiter’s 34th trip around the giant.

Watch Out! Amateur Astronomer Watches as Jupiter Gets Whacked

Jupiter is the OG best friend in the solar system. It finds all the tiny little comets and asteroids heading for the vulnerable inner planets and takes one for the team, chewing up the dangerous rocks in its thick atmosphere. It happened again just recently, and this time an amateur astronomer caught it in the act.

Why Mercury Matters

At first, the planet Mercury isn't much to look at. It has a surface only a mother could love, as desolate and empty as the Moon and pock-marked with crater after crater. But this planet has a secret, which has folks wanting to know more.

Six Planets are Retrograde, What Does that Mean for You?

Spoiler alert: It's an optical illusion.

Saving Earth from Killer Asteroids

Only about 40% of an estimated 25,000 near-Earth asteroids with the potential to destroy the planet have been detected. Scientist Dr. Ed Lu, along with his nonprofit B612 are working to create a way to detect the other 60%.

Related To: